Preview Dialing: Manual v. Automatic?
by Joseph Sanscrainte
As everyone in the teleservices industry knows, the FCC has determined
that if you?re using a predictive dialer to make calls, you have to scrub
out wireless numbers. Specifically, under the Telephone Consumer
Protection Act of 1991, as well as regulations issued by the FCC, it is
prohibited for any entity to call a wireless number, without prior consent
or in the event of an emergency, if the entity uses an "automatic
telephone dialing system to make the call.? The pertinent regulations
state:
No person or entity may . . . [i]nitiate any telephone call (other
than a call made for emergency purposes or made with the prior express
consent of the called party) using an automatic telephone dialing system
or an artificial or prerecorded voice . . . [t]o any telephone number
assigned to a . . . cellular telephone service.
The terms automatic telephone dialing system and autodialer mean
equipment which has the capacity to store or produce telephone numbers
to be called using a random or sequential number generator and to dial
such numbers.
The question that I keep hearing, however, is: "What about preview
dialing? Is that an automatic telephone dialing system (ATDS)? Even though
no call gets made unless a human presses a button, the underlying
technology has the ?capacity? to store or produce telephone numbers to be
called, right??
Well . . . the devil is in the details. At the time of the passage of
the TCPA in 1991, the above rule had an immediate impact - entities that
were making use of automatic telephone dialing systems (ATDS) to generate
calls randomly or via sequential dialing were unable to do so in
the context of calling wireless numbers. It was not until 2003, however,
that the full impact of this language was made clear to the telemarketing
industry. In a rulemaking dated July 25, 2003, the FCC considered the
question of whether a predictive dialer met the definition of an ATDS
given in the TCPA. The key part of the FCC?s reasoning in determining that
a predictive dialer was, in fact, an ATDS, is as follows:
The TCPA defines an "automatic telephone dialing system" as
"equipment which has the capacity (A) to store or produce telephone
numbers to be called, using a random or sequential number generator; and
(B) to dial such numbers." The statutory definition contemplates
autodialing equipment that either stores or produces numbers. It also
provides that, in order to be considered an "automatic telephone dialing
system," the equipment need only have the "capacity to store or produce
telephone numbers. * * * The basic function of such equipment, however,
has not changed--the capacity to dial numbers without human
intervention. Coupled with the fact that autodialers can dial
thousands of numbers in a short period of time, calls to these specified
categories of numbers are particularly troublesome.
The FCC concluded essentially that any equipment that has the
"capacity to dial numbers without human intervention? and that can
"dial thousands of numbers in a short period of time? renders such
equipment an ATDS and thus subject to the TCPA?s prohibition against
dialing wireless numbers. It?s the FCC?s use of the term "human
intervention,? however, that provides a rationale in support of the
contention that preview dialing would not be considered an ATDS -
when preview dialing is used, a call is only placed when a human
intervenes and makes a determination that the call will be made.
Telemarketing compliance is already difficult enough - why make it more
so by adding preview dialing to the ATDS mix? It seems pretty
straightforward - a human being is NOT an "automatic telephone dialing
system.?
Free Compliance Webinar: Top 10 Compliance Mistakes
- How to Avoid Investigations
Learn about the top 10 mistakes that can keep you out of
legal hot water when conducting inbound or outbound consumer telephone
marketing campaigns from guest speaker and leading contact center legal
expert, attorney Michele Shuster.
Date: November 10, 2010 Time: 1:00 PM -
2:00 PM EST (10:00 AM - 11:00 AM PST) Register Today: https://www1.gotomeeting.com/register/610845112
|